Award Winning & Highly Rated
I was featured as a Trailblazer by the prestigious New York Law Journal in 2019 and have a perfect 10.0 Superb rating from AVVO. I have also been voted Best Lawyer on Long Island 5 consecutive years.
There is no Lawyer fighting harder than me!
I treasure every single one of my clients and treat every case as if it were my own family member. I pride myself on fighting for the underdog and I will fight for you.
31+ Years Experience
Since graduating from Hofstra Law School in 1994, I have successfully handled more than 2,000 criminal cases ranging from minor violations to serious felonies.
24/7 Personal Accessibility
When you hire me, you get my personal cell phone number. I am available to my clients when they need me most, because I understand that legal emergencies do not happen during business hours.
Smithtown Criminal Lawyer
Experienced Smithtown Criminal Defense Attorney
If you have been arrested or charged with a crime in Smithtown, you need an experienced criminal defense attorney who understands Suffolk County courts and knows how to protect your rights. As a criminal defense lawyer with over 31 years of experience, I have successfully defended thousands of clients facing criminal charges throughout Smithtown and the surrounding areas, from the historic downtown district to the residential neighborhoods along Jericho Turnpike.
Smithtown’s unique character as one of Suffolk County’s most historic and affluent communities means that criminal cases here often receive heightened attention from law enforcement and prosecutors. Whether you were arrested by the Suffolk County Police Department’s 4th Precinct, the New York State Police, or are facing charges related to an incident at one of Smithtown’s many local businesses or residential areas, the consequences of a criminal conviction can be devastating to your reputation, career, and freedom.
Since graduating from Hofstra Law School in 1994, I have handled more than 2,000 criminal cases ranging from minor violations to serious felonies. My approach combines aggressive legal defense with personalized client service. When you hire me, you get my personal cell phone number and 24/7 accessibility. I understand that being charged with a crime is one of the most stressful experiences you can face, and I am committed to guiding you through every step of the process.
If you have been arrested in Smithtown, time is critical. You need to act quickly to protect your rights and build a strong defense. Contact me today at (631) 265-1052 for a free consultation.
Protect your rights. Protect your freedom. Protect your future.
Related Services:
Case Results
Drug Possession
CASE DISMISSED
Client was a passenger in a vehicle stopped on Jericho Turnpike in Smithtown. Police found cocaine in the center console and charged all occupants. We demonstrated our client had no knowledge of the drugs. Prosecution dismissed all charges.
DWI
ACQUITTED AFTER TRIAL
Client arrested for DWI on Main Street in Smithtown. Officer claimed client failed field sobriety tests. We challenged the stop as lacking reasonable suspicion and the tests as improperly administered. Jury returned not guilty verdict.
Petit Larceny
ACD (Dismissed)
College student charged with shoplifting at Smithtown mall. Negotiated Adjournment in Contemplation of Dismissal. Charges dismissed and sealed after six months, preserving clients clean record.
Domestic Violence
CASE DROPPED
Client arrested after domestic dispute in Smithtown home. Investigation revealed false accusations made during contentious divorce. Prosecution declined to prosecute after we presented exculpatory evidence.
Assault
REDUCED TO VIOLATION
Client involved in altercation at Smithtown bar. Faced felony assault charge. Negotiated reduction to disorderly conduct violation, avoiding criminal record and jail time.
Weapons Possession
CASE DISMISSED
Client charged with possessing unregistered firearm found during traffic stop. Successfully challenged search as unconstitutional. All evidence suppressed, case dismissed.
Criminal Contempt
DISMISSED
Client accused of violating order of protection. Demonstrated that alleged contact was accidental and unintentional. Charges dismissed at preliminary hearing.
Multiple Felonies
REDUCED TO MISDEMEANOR
Client facing multiple felony charges including burglary and larceny. Through intensive investigation and negotiation, secured plea to single misdemeanor with probation, avoiding state prison.
Meet Ed Palermo
Meet Ed Palermo – Your Smithtown Criminal Defense Lawyer
I am Edward Palermo, a Suffolk County criminal defense attorney with over three decades of experience protecting the rights of individuals accused of crimes throughout Long Island. Since graduating from Hofstra Law School in 1994, I have dedicated my career to defending individuals facing criminal charges, from misdemeanor offenses to serious felonies.
Over the past 31 years, I have successfully handled more than 2,000 criminal cases. This extensive experience has given me deep insight into how prosecutors build cases and, more importantly, how to effectively challenge them. I have represented clients in every courthouse in Suffolk County and have developed strong working relationships with judges, prosecutors, and court personnel.
What sets my practice apart is my commitment to accessibility and personalized service. Unlike large firms where you may never speak to your attorney, I provide every client with my personal cell phone number. You can reach me directly at (631) 903-3733 when you need answers or reassurance.
My track record speaks for itself. I have been named Best Lawyer on Long Island for five consecutive years by the Long Island Press, recognized as a NY Law Journal Trailblazer, and maintain a 10.0 AVVO Rating. But more important than any award is the trust my clients place in me during their most difficult moments.
When you choose me as your Smithtown criminal defense attorney, you get:
- Personal attention – You work directly with me, not a junior associate
- 24/7 accessibility – My cell phone is always on
- Proven results – Thousands of successful case outcomes
- Local knowledge – Deep familiarity with Suffolk County courts and prosecutors
- Aggressive defense – I fight for the best possible outcome in every case
If you are facing criminal charges in Smithtown, don’t face them alone. Let me put my experience to work for you.
Testimonials
"...very hard working and did his best to get me a favorable outcome."
I hired attorney Ed Palermo when I was facing robbery charges last year. He was very hard working and did his best to get me a favorable outcome. Thank you, Ed!
Gabrielle S.
"Ed Palermo is your best option."
Attorney Palermo was my domestic violence defense lawyer when I was accused of domestic violence. I had a really hard time when I was charged but attorney Palermo was there to make the process easier. There's no one else I would recommend. If you are facing domestic violence charges in New York, Ed Palermo is your best option.
Jack B.
"He is extremely sharp in court..."
I had reverently used Ed Palermo as my attorney in a criminal case. Was extremely pleased with the outcome. He is extremely sharp in court and reached the exact outcome we had discussed prior. I would strongly recommend to anyone.
Billy P.
"So grateful!"
Having attorney Ed Palermo as my defense attorney was an amazing experience. He knew the law inside and out and kept me updated throughout my case. So grateful!
Richie W.
"Miracle worker and such a gentleman."
I searched for a lawyer for a friend of mine and hands down Ed is the Best lawyer on Long Island. The Best!!!!!!! I’d refer him to anyone. Miracle worker and such a gentleman.
Catherine F.
"... took care of me through every stage."
Ed guided and took care of me through every stage. Any question I had or concern he would explain the situation, options and how we overcome it to resolve the best outcome for me.
Ed H.
Online Ratings
Smithtown Criminal Defense Experience
Understanding Criminal Charges in Smithtown
The Smithtown Criminal Justice Environment
Smithtown presents a unique environment for criminal defense due to its historic character, affluent demographics, and active law enforcement presence. As one of the original towns in Suffolk County, Smithtown has a well-established legal community and court system that handles a wide variety of criminal matters.
The Suffolk County Police Department’s 4th Precinct maintains primary jurisdiction over Smithtown criminal enforcement. This precinct covers not only Smithtown but also the neighboring communities of Nesconset, St. James, and parts of Lake Grove. The 4th Precinct is known for proactive policing and maintains a visible presence throughout the community, particularly along major commercial corridors.
Local enforcement patterns in Smithtown include:
- Patrols along Jericho Turnpike – Major commercial corridor with numerous businesses
- Main Street enforcement – Historic downtown area with shops and restaurants
- Residential neighborhood patrols – Responding to domestic incidents and property crimes
- State Police presence on Northern State Parkway and Long Island Expressway
- DWI checkpoints during holidays and special events
Understanding these enforcement patterns is crucial for building an effective defense. Many criminal cases in Smithtown originate from traffic stops, business disputes, domestic incidents, or property-related complaints.
Where Smithtown Criminal Cases Are Heard
Criminal cases originating in Smithtown are primarily prosecuted in the First District Court in Central Islip. This court is located at:
First District Court
400 Carleton Avenue
Central Islip, NY 11722
Phone: (631) 462-3900
The First District Court handles all misdemeanor criminal matters from Smithtown, including DWI, petit larceny, assault, drug possession, and other violations. Felony cases are transferred to Suffolk County Court in Riverhead.
Types of Criminal Cases We Handle in Smithtown
Drug Crimes
Drug-related offenses are among the most common criminal charges in Smithtown. These cases range from simple possession of marijuana or controlled substances to more serious charges involving distribution or sale. New York’s drug laws have evolved significantly in recent years, with many offenses now eligible for treatment alternatives or diversion programs. Learn more about drug possession defense.
DWI and Traffic Offenses
Driving While Intoxicated (DWI) cases are aggressively prosecuted in Smithtown, particularly along major routes like Jericho Turnpike and the Northern State Parkway. First-time offenders may be eligible for reduced charges or diversion programs. Learn more about Smithtown DWI defense.
Domestic Violence
Domestic violence allegations in Smithtown are taken extremely seriously by law enforcement and prosecutors. These cases often involve mandatory arrest policies and can result in orders of protection. False accusations require immediate and aggressive defense. Learn more about domestic violence defense.
Assault and Violent Crimes
Assault charges in Smithtown can range from simple third-degree assault to more serious felony charges involving weapons or serious injury. Bar fights, domestic incidents, and altercations at public events are common sources of assault charges.
Petit Larceny and Shoplifting
With Smithtown’s extensive retail corridors along Jericho Turnpike and Main Street, shoplifting and petit larceny charges are common. These cases often involve first-time offenders who made poor decisions.
Gun and Weapons Charges
New York has some of the strictest weapons laws in the nation. Possession of firearms, knives, or other weapons can result in serious criminal charges, even for law-abiding citizens who may not realize they are violating the law. Learn more about gun charge defense.
Defense Strategies for Smithtown Criminal Cases
Challenging Illegal Searches and Seizures
The Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable searches and seizures. Police must have probable cause, a warrant, or valid consent to search. Evidence obtained through illegal searches can be suppressed, often resulting in dismissed charges.
Miranda Rights Violations
If police failed to read you your Miranda rights before custodial interrogation, any statements you made may be inadmissible in court. This can severely weaken the prosecution’s case.
Witness Credibility Challenges
Many criminal cases rely heavily on witness testimony. We investigate witnesses’ backgrounds, motives, and prior inconsistent statements to challenge their credibility.
Self-Defense
In assault cases, New York law recognizes the right to use reasonable force to defend yourself or others. We gather evidence to support self-defense claims.
Why Choose a Local Smithtown Criminal Defense Attorney
While any New York attorney can represent you in a criminal case, choosing a lawyer with specific experience in Smithtown and Suffolk County offers significant advantages:
- Familiarity with local courts – Understanding of First District Court procedures and personnel
- Knowledge of local enforcement – Awareness of 4th Precinct practices
- Relationships with prosecutors – Established credibility with Suffolk County DA’s Office
- Understanding of the community – Knowledge of Smithtown’s unique characteristics
- Accessibility – Local presence for meetings and court appearances
If you are facing criminal charges in Smithtown, don’t wait to seek legal help. The sooner you contact an experienced attorney, the more options you have for protecting your rights and your future.
Call (631) 265-1052 now for a free consultation
Frequently Asked Questions About Smithtown Criminal Cases
Where do I go to court for a criminal case in Smithtown?
Smithtown criminal cases are heard at the First District Court in Central Islip, located at 400 Carleton Avenue. Misdemeanor cases remain there; felonies are transferred to Suffolk County Court in Riverhead.
What should I do if I’m arrested in Smithtown?
Remain silent, ask for an attorney, and do not discuss your case with anyone except your lawyer. Contact an experienced criminal defense attorney immediately. Do not consent to any searches.
How much does a criminal lawyer cost in Suffolk County?
Fees vary based on case complexity, the charges, and whether the case goes to trial. I offer free consultations to discuss your case and provide a clear fee structure. Payment plans are often available.
Can criminal charges be dismissed in Smithtown?
Yes, charges can be dismissed for various reasons including illegal searches, lack of evidence, constitutional violations, or successful completion of diversion programs. Each case is unique.
What is the difference between a misdemeanor and felony?
Misdemeanors are less serious crimes punishable by up to one year in jail. Felonies are more serious crimes punishable by more than one year in state prison. The specific charges determine potential penalties.
Will I go to jail for a first offense?
Not necessarily. Many first-time offenders are eligible for alternative sentencing, probation, or diversion programs. Factors include the nature of the offense, your criminal history, and the strength of the defense.
Can I get a public defender in Suffolk County?
If you cannot afford an attorney, you may qualify for a public defender or assigned counsel. However, private attorneys often provide more personalized attention and have lighter caseloads.
How long does a criminal case take in Suffolk County?
Most criminal cases take 3-6 months to resolve, though complex cases or trials may take longer. The court typically schedules multiple appearances to allow for discovery and potential plea negotiations.
What is an order of protection?
An order of protection (restraining order) may be issued in domestic violence or assault cases, prohibiting contact with the alleged victim. Violating an order results in additional criminal charges.
Why should I hire a local Smithtown attorney?
Local attorneys know the courts, prosecutors, and procedures specific to Suffolk County. This local knowledge and established relationships often result in better outcomes for clients.
Honors & Recognition
