Over 31 years · Long Island criminal defense
Over 31 years · Long Island criminal defense
I've personally defended over 2,000 people across Nassau & Suffolk for 31 years. Tell me what happened and I'll text you back.
You have been charged with grand larceny in Suffolk County, or you have learned you are under investigation, and the fear is specific: a felony conviction, jail, and a permanent record that follows you through every job application and professional review for the rest of your life. These cases are serious, and Suffolk prosecutes them meaningfully. But they are also among the most workable serious felonies there are, if the right things happen early.
Here is what you are actually facing, and where the defense lives.
Grand larceny is graded entirely by dollar amount, and that number controls everything, the felony class, the prison exposure, and how willing the District Attorney is to move. The higher the amount, the harder the posture. But even on high-dollar cases, and even where the District Attorney is initially demanding jail, there is often a path to a result that protects your record and your freedom. I have defended these cases in Suffolk for 31 years. For the full picture of how I handle criminal matters here, start with my Suffolk County criminal defense page.
New York grades larceny by the value of what was allegedly taken, and one dollar can be the line between a misdemeanor and a felony. Understanding exactly where your case falls is the first step, because the degree drives everything that follows.
| Charge | Value | Class | Max prison |
|---|---|---|---|
| Petit larceny (PL 155.25) | $1,000 or less | A misdemeanor | 1 year (jail) |
| Grand larceny 4th (PL 155.30) | over $1,000 to $3,000 | E felony | 4 years |
| Grand larceny 3rd (PL 155.35) | over $3,000 to $50,000 | D felony | 7 years |
| Grand larceny 2nd (PL 155.40) | over $50,000 to $1 million | C felony | 15 years |
| Grand larceny 1st (PL 155.42) | over $1 million | B felony | 25 years |
The value is measured at present-day worth, not original purchase price, which matters more than people expect, an item bought years ago may be worth far less today, and that can pull a case down a degree or out of felony territory entirely. Certain property is grand larceny regardless of amount, including a credit or debit card, anything taken directly from a person, and anything obtained by extortion. Because the number controls the case, the value itself is frequently the first thing worth fighting over. The full statutory framework is in Penal Law Article 155.
Grand larceny charges in Suffolk County can carry serious felony consequences, with the severity of the charge largely determined by the value of the property allegedly taken.
I want to be honest with you about the posture here, because it is neither as hopeless as you may fear nor as easy as some lawyers will suggest.
Grand larceny and white-collar cases are not treated as harshly in Suffolk as violent felonies are. But they are prosecuted meaningfully, and the Suffolk County District Attorney’s white-collar and financial-crime bureau has a reputation for not going lightly, especially when the dollar amount is high or the alleged victim is vulnerable, an elderly person, someone in the defendant’s care, someone who trusted them. On high-value felonies, the office often will not reduce the charge at all as an opening position.
That opening position is not the end of the story, though. It is where the work begins. I have avoided jail for clients on many occasions where a significant dollar amount was involved, and in a number of cases I have gotten the charge reduced to a misdemeanor, and at times, on the right facts, all the way down to a non-criminal violation. The difference between the opening demand and the final result is the defense.
On a high-dollar grand larceny, the District Attorney’s first position is often no reduction and jail. That is the starting point, not the outcome. What happens between there and the disposition is where an experienced defense earns its keep.
Edward R. Palermo, Esq. Long Island Criminal & DWI Defense
This is a genuine, practical advantage, and it is specific to how I practice. The Suffolk County District Attorney’s white-collar bureau is located in Hauppauge, very close to my office. I am there regularly, meeting with the assistant district attorneys and the supervisors who make the decisions on these cases, and I have a very good relationship with the bureau and with many of the people in supervisory positions.
That does not mean cases are handed to me. It means I can open a credible, direct line of communication early, before positions harden, and have a real conversation about the facts, the weaknesses, and a resolution that fits. On white-collar cases, where so much turns on how the office chooses to exercise its discretion, being known and trusted by the bureau that decides these cases is worth a great deal.
Restitution changes the conversationIn financial cases, the alleged victim’s loss is often at the center of what the District Attorney wants. A well-structured restitution arrangement, offered at the right time, can transform the negotiation, sometimes turning a jail demand into a probationary sentence, or a felony into a reduced charge. Timing and presentation are everything.
These are real Suffolk results. Prior outcomes never guarantee a future one, and every case turns on its own facts, but they show what is possible when these cases are handled properly.
In one case, my client was charged with grand larceny and facing a felony with up to four years in jail. Through careful work with the District Attorney’s office, I structured a disposition in which the client completed 175 hours of community service and a period of interim TASC monitoring, a program that confirms no illegal drug use and no new arrests over a twelve-month period. At the end of that period, the client pleaded guilty to a non-criminal violation, not a crime, with a conditional discharge. The client went from a potential felony and up to four years in jail to a sealed violation with no criminal record at all.
In another, my client was alleged to have stolen over $100,000 from a vulnerable senior citizen she had been caring for, exactly the kind of high-dollar, vulnerable-victim case the white-collar bureau treats most seriously. The District Attorney’s office was initially adamant about jail time. I was able to negotiate a disposition of a probationary sentence with restitution, keeping my client out of jail entirely.
Charged with grand larceny in Suffolk County?
The first position is rarely the last. Tell me what happened and I’ll text you back personally, usually within the hour.
click here to text my cell
TEXT ED NOW
Suffolk (631) 265-1052
Nassau (516) 280-2160
Grand larceny is rarely charged alone. Financial cases frequently come with additional felonies that can raise the exposure and complicate the defense, and the white-collar bureau often stacks them.
When cases involve ongoing conduct, the District Attorney may aggregate the amounts across many transactions to push the total into a higher degree. Challenging that aggregation, and the valuation behind it, is often central to the defense. For workplace theft specifically, see my embezzlement page.
For most of my grand larceny clients, the sentence is not even their biggest fear. It is the record. A felony larceny or fraud conviction is a permanent mark that can end a career, especially for anyone in a licensed or fiduciary role, accountants, attorneys, financial professionals, healthcare workers, anyone with access to money or a professional license. It can trigger licensing board review, bar you from positions of financial trust, and, for non-citizens, a larceny or fraud conviction is treated as a crime involving moral turpitude with serious immigration consequences.
This is exactly why keeping the disposition off your record, through a reduction to a non-criminal violation, a dismissal, or a plea that seals, is so often worth more than shaving time off a sentence. Any resolution has to be evaluated with these collateral consequences at the center, not as an afterthought.
I start with the number, because the number is the charge. I examine how the District Attorney valued the property, whether that valuation holds up at present-day worth, and whether aggregation across transactions was proper, because pulling the value below a threshold can drop the degree or defeat the felony entirely. I look at intent, which the prosecution must prove and which is frequently the weakest part of a financial case, many larceny allegations are really disputes over authorization, ownership, or a genuine misunderstanding, not theft.
Where the evidence supports a resolution rather than a trial, I move early, before indictment where possible, using my relationship with the white-collar bureau in Hauppauge and, in the right case, a structured restitution arrangement to reshape what the office is willing to do. And I handle the collateral consequences deliberately, protecting the license and the record, not just the sentence. I handle every case personally, from the first call to the last court date.
Theft becomes grand larceny once the value of the property exceeds $1,000. At or below that amount it is generally petit larceny, a class A misdemeanor. Over $1,000 to $3,000 is grand larceny in the fourth degree, a class E felony; over $3,000 to $50,000 is third degree, a class D felony; over $50,000 to $1 million is second degree, a class C felony; and over $1 million is first degree, a class B felony. Certain property, including a credit or debit card, anything taken from a person, or anything obtained by extortion, is grand larceny regardless of the amount.
Not necessarily, even on serious cases. For a first offender without a prior record, there is no mandatory prison sentence on the lower degrees, and probation or a non-custodial disposition is often achievable. The Suffolk County District Attorney’s white-collar bureau does take these cases seriously, especially where the dollar amount is high or the victim is vulnerable, and its opening position on a high-value felony is frequently jail. But I have kept many clients out of jail in exactly those situations, including a case involving over $100,000 taken from a vulnerable senior, which I resolved to probation with restitution rather than incarceration.
Sometimes, and it is often the central goal. A reduction to a misdemeanor eliminates the felony record and the prison exposure, and in the right case a charge can be reduced all the way to a non-criminal violation that seals, leaving no criminal record at all. I obtained exactly that in a recent case, where a client facing a grand larceny felony completed community service and a period of monitoring and then pleaded to a sealed violation. Whether a reduction is achievable depends on the dollar amount, the strength of the evidence, your background, and how the case is approached with the District Attorney’s office.
By present-day market value at the time of the alleged theft, not the original purchase price. This distinction matters, because an item bought years ago may be worth substantially less now, and a lower value can drop the charge to a lesser degree or below the felony threshold entirely. In cases involving many transactions, the District Attorney may try to aggregate the amounts to reach a higher degree, and challenging both the valuation and the aggregation is frequently central to the defense. Because the value controls the entire case, it is often the first thing worth contesting.
Not automatically, but restitution can significantly change the outcome. Repaying the alleged loss does not by itself dismiss a criminal charge, only the District Attorney can agree to reduce or drop the case. However, in financial cases the victim’s loss is often at the center of what the prosecution cares about, and a well-structured restitution arrangement offered at the right time can reshape the negotiation, sometimes turning a jail demand into probation, or a felony into a reduced charge. Timing and presentation matter greatly, which is why restitution should be handled strategically through counsel, not offered blindly.
Yes, significantly. The Suffolk County District Attorney’s white-collar bureau treats cases involving vulnerable victims, elderly people, individuals in the defendant’s care, or those in a position of trust, far more seriously, and its opening posture in these cases is often the toughest. That makes experienced, early representation especially important. Even so, these cases can be resolved favorably. I represented a client accused of taking over $100,000 from a vulnerable senior she cared for, where the office initially demanded jail, and I negotiated a probationary sentence with restitution that kept her out of custody.
Financial cases are rarely a single charge. Grand larceny frequently travels with falsifying business records, forgery and criminal possession of a forged instrument, criminal possession of stolen property, identity theft, credit or debit card fraud, and scheme to defraud when a course of conduct is alleged. These additional felonies can raise the exposure and complicate the plea calculus, and the white-collar bureau often charges them together. Understanding how the charges interact, and which are truly supported by the evidence, is part of building the defense and the negotiation strategy.
Very likely, and for many clients this is the biggest concern. A larceny or fraud conviction is a crime of dishonesty, which is especially damaging for anyone in a licensed or fiduciary role, accountants, attorneys, financial professionals, healthcare workers, or anyone with access to money. It can trigger professional licensing review, bar you from positions of financial trust, and end a career. For non-citizens it is treated as a crime involving moral turpitude with serious immigration consequences. This is precisely why keeping the conviction off your record is so often worth more than reducing the sentence, and why the collateral consequences have to be central to the strategy.
TASC is a monitoring program that confirms a defendant has no illegal drug use and no new arrests over a set period, often twelve months. In the right case, agreeing to a period of interim TASC monitoring, sometimes combined with community service, can be part of a disposition that ultimately reduces a felony to a non-criminal violation. In a recent grand larceny case I resolved this way, the client completed 175 hours of community service and interim TASC, then pleaded to a sealed violation rather than a crime. Whether this path is available depends on the facts and on negotiation with the District Attorney’s office.
Because these cases turn heavily on prosecutorial discretion, and that discretion is exercised by the specific assistant district attorneys and supervisors in the white-collar bureau, which is located in Hauppauge. An attorney who is known and trusted by that bureau, who is in that office regularly and can open a credible conversation early, is in a materially better position to shape the outcome than one who is not. I have a long-standing, good relationship with the bureau and many of its supervisors. That does not mean cases are handed to me; it means I can get to the right people early and be taken seriously when I raise a genuine issue.
A grand larceny charge, or even the first sign that you are under investigation, is the moment to get experienced counsel involved, because the earliest decisions, what you say, what you preserve, whether restitution is offered and how, shape everything that follows. Do not talk to investigators, and do not try to explain your way out of it, before you talk to me.
I have represented more than 2,000 clients across Suffolk and Nassau over 31 years, and I have never worked for the other side. For the full picture of how I defend criminal cases in this county, see my Suffolk County criminal defense page, or look through my case results.
Your record and your career are on the line.
Free and confidential. I answer my own phone, and I’ll tell you honestly where you stand.
click here to text my cell
TEXT ED NOW
Suffolk (631) 265-1052
Nassau (516) 280-2160
Legal Authority & Editorial Review
This article was written and reviewed by Edward Palermo, a Long Island criminal defense and DWI attorney with more than 31 years of courtroom experience and over 2,000 clients personally represented across Nassau and Suffolk Counties.
Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The information on this page is for general educational purposes and is not legal advice; reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship.
Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Legal disclaimer
I represented a Stony Brook University student charged with Grand Larceny. I convinced the District Attorney to grant a dismissal after six months without a re-arrest. My client's reputation, freedom, and student visa were all protected.
Client Reviews
“Ed Palermo is an excellent and very professional attorney. He…”
Ed Palermo is an excellent and very professional attorney. He works to achieve the best possible outcome for the client. He is always very personable and easy to talk to.
“Attorney Rafael Zapata is outstanding. With over 25 years of…”
Attorney Rafael Zapata is outstanding. With over 25 years of criminal defense experience and the ability to serve clients in both English and Spanish, he makes the process smooth and clear for everyone. His professionalism and dedication truly set him apart. Highly recommend this firm for anyone needing trusted legal representation.
“I highly recommend Ed Palermo as a top-notch criminal defense…”
I highly recommend Ed Palermo as a top-notch criminal defense lawyer. He represented a family member of mine with incredible skill, dedication, and professionalism. From the very beginning, Ed Palermo took the time to explain every step of the legal process, answered all our questions, and provided unwavering support. He fought tirelessly to ensure the best possible outcome, and thanks to his hard work and expertise, our family member’s case was resolved successfully. Ed Palermo is not only highly knowledgeable but also genuinely cares about his clients, treating them with respect and compassion. If you need a strong, reliable, and experienced defense attorney, I wholeheartedly recommend Ed Palermo.
“great lawyer, he has helped me out with a couple…”
great lawyer, he has helped me out with a couple cases now and every time it’s a win. great price for the amazing work that he does. i will always call him if needed.
“Edward Palermo is confident, smart, and extremely knowledgeable. He knows…”
Edward Palermo is confident, smart, and extremely knowledgeable. He knows everything about the law. He knows how to effectively argue a case and is always available when you have a question. He is very passionate and genuinely cares about his clients and their future.
“Edward Palermo is an extremely gifted attorney. I know well…”
Edward Palermo is an extremely gifted attorney. I know well as he represented me and my family recently. Previously I worked for a number of lawyers over the years so can well differentiate between the not so good and the great. Ed is great. He's well versed in the law, and has extreme expertise in dealing with the Police, District Attorneys and most importantly Judges as well. He leaves his clients feeling confident and in good hands. Ed goes the extra mile for you and always gets back to you to answer any questions you have. He's a fantastic attorney!
