Award Winning &
Highly Rated
I have been voted "Best Lawyer on Long Island for the last 5 years, I was featured as a Trailblazer by the prestigious New York Law Journal in 2019 and have a perfect 10 “superb” rating from AVVO.
There is no Lawyer fighting harder than me!
I treasure my clients and truly appreciate that they retain me to defend them in matters of such importance. I will do everything in my power to get you a great result.
I am always directly available to my clients
All of my clients receive my personal cell phone number. Clients can contact me anytime. New clients can feel free to text me anytime as well on my cell (631) 903-3733
Speak Directly To Ed Today
We understand this can be one of the most embarrassing, stressful times in their lives. We are here to help.
I will answer all of your questions. I will explain the DWI charges you face. I will explain potential strategies to win your case. New clients ALWAYS feel better after they speak to me.
- Ed Palermo
Montauk Criminal Defense Attorney
If you’ve been arrested or you’re under investigation in Montauk, the ground can shift under you fast. One minute you’re living your life, the next you’re staring at a court date, a possible order of protection, or calls from detectives that you don’t know how to handle.
I’m Ed Palermo, and I’ve spent more than 30 years defending people across Long Island—including countless clients from Montauk and the East End. If you need a Montauk criminal defense attorney who will take your situation seriously, move quickly, and fight for the best possible outcome, I’m here to help.
Call my East Hampton office at (631) 265-1051 or text me directly at (631) 903-3733. I answer personally.
A criminal charge doesn’t just threaten your record. It can impact your job, your professional license, your ability to travel, your family life, and your future housing options. The earlier you have a defense strategy in place, the more control you have over what happens next.
Why Montauk Clients Choose Ed Palermo
There’s a difference between a lawyer who processes cases and a lawyer who builds a defense around your life, your risk level, and the facts. Here’s why clients across the East End trust me with their cases:
30+ years of criminal defense experience. I’ve represented over 2,000 Long Island and NYC residents throughout my career, including more than 1,000 DWI cases alone.
Voted Best Lawyer on Long Island 5 consecutive years. My clients have recognized my dedication by voting me Best Lawyer on Long Island in 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, and 2023.
NY Law Journal “Trailblazer” recognition. I was honored by the prestigious New York Law Journal as a Trailblazer in 2019.
Perfect 10.0 “Superb” AVVO rating. Independent review confirms my reputation for excellence.
Top 1% of attorneys nationwide. National Association of Distinguished Counsel recognition.
You get my personal cell phone. Every client receives my direct number. When you’re facing criminal charges, you deserve to reach your attorney—not a receptionist or paralegal.
My approach is straightforward:
- I move fast to protect you from avoidable mistakes
- I pressure-test the prosecution’s case early, not later
- I focus on outcomes, not courtroom theatrics
- I treat every client like the stakes matter—because they do
Whether you were arrested after a stop on Montauk Highway, involved in an incident near local bars or restaurants, or accused of something stemming from a property dispute, the details matter. Small facts become big leverage in a criminal case.
What to Do If Police Want to Talk to You
If a detective calls and says they “just want to ask questions,” you should assume they are building a case. Your best move is to stay calm, be polite, and do not discuss the facts without counsel.
Do NOT:
- Explain, justify, or try to clear things up on the phone
- Consent to searches of your home, car, or phone
- Assume “cooperating” means the matter goes away
- Post anything about the situation on social media
DO:
- Get legal advice before you make any statement
- Be polite but firm: “I’d like to speak with my attorney first”
- Write down everything you remember about the incident
- Call me immediately at (631) 265-1051
In many cases, the biggest damage comes from what someone says early—before they understand the exposure.
Notable DWI Results
Edward represented a New Jersey Businessman charged with DWI
East Hampton DWI Lawyer Edward Palermo negotiates a reduction of the criminal charges to a non-criminal traffic violation.
Medical Doctor charged with DWI
Edward Palermo negotiates reduction to simple traffic infraction to insure no negative impact on Doctor’s career.
Pennsylvania business man charged with DWI
East Hampton DWI Lawyer Edward Palermo negotiates a reduced charge of only a single traffic violation.
Edward Palermo represented student at Stony Brook University charged with DWI
Again, Edward negotiates a reduction of the criminal charges to a non-criminal traffic violation.
Edward Palermo represented a Brooklyn resident in a DWI charge on Long Island
As a successful real estate broker, the client was concerned about the effect a criminal conviction would have on his professional license and livelihood. The District Attorney would not reduce the charge to a non-criminal traffic violation because the client was previously arrested for driving while intoxicated. Edward found a flaw in the prosecution’s handling of the case and made a motion to dismiss the case. The motion was granted in its entirety and the case was completely DISMISSED.
Client charged with aggravated DWI
Client is a financial professional and his future career advancement was in jeopardy if convicted of this serious misdemeanor crime. The Suffolk County District Attorney VERY RARELY agrees to reduce such a charge because of the elevated Blood Alcohol Content finding by police. Long Island DWI Attorney Edward Palermo negotiated an extremely favorable resolution which will lead to the reduction of the aggravated DWI to a simple traffic infraction after 1 year of good behavior by the client. His professional license and future career opportunities are secure.
Client charged with DWI after driving his vehicle into a residential home
The District Attorney originally recommended jail time. Long Island DWI Lawyer Edward Palermo negotiated a very favorable outcome which will lead to dismissal of criminal charges and only a traffic violation after 1 year of good conduct by client.
Client charged with aggravated DWI and additional violations with a motor vehicle accident
Edward Palermo scheduled the matter for trial before The Honorable Joseph Girardi of the Nassau County First District Court. First, Edward was able to obtain dismissal of the additional violations after motion during the trial and the client was then found NOT GUILTY of the aggravated DWI charge after trial. All charges dismissed and client, who is a teacher, was able to resume his life and career with a clean record.
Meet Ed Palermo
I am a Suffolk County DWI Lawyer with more than 30 years of experience. I concentrate my practice on helping individuals who face DWI charges. I have represented more than 1000 Long Island and NYC residents over my career.
I am proud of my track record of success. Helping my clients is my only goal. If you or a loved one needs a Long Island DWI Lawyer, please do not hesitate to call me today. I am always here to help.
There is no substitute for experience when finding a Long Island DWI Attorney. I am always happy to extend my family of clients. I will fight for you and make sure that you always feel protected and secure.
Testimonials
"...very hard working and did his best to get me a favorable outcome."
I hired attorney Ed Palermo when I was facing robbery charges last year. He was very hard working and did his best to get me a favorable outcome. Thank you, Ed!
Gabrielle S.
"Ed Palermo is your best option."
Attorney Palermo was my domestic violence defense lawyer when I was accused of domestic violence. I had a really hard time when I was charged but attorney Palermo was there to make the process easier. There's no one else I would recommend. If you are facing domestic violence charges in New York, Ed Palermo is your best option.
Jack B.
"He is extremely sharp in court..."
I had reverently used Ed Palermo as my attorney in a criminal case. Was extremely pleased with the outcome. He is extremely sharp in court and reached the exact outcome we had discussed prior. I would strongly recommend to anyone.
Billy P.
"So grateful!"
Having attorney Ed Palermo as my defense attorney was an amazing experience. He knew the law inside and out and kept me updated throughout my case. So grateful!
Richie W.
"Miracle worker and such a gentleman."
I searched for a lawyer for a friend of mine and hands down Ed is the Best lawyer on Long Island. The Best!!!!!!! I’d refer him to anyone. Miracle worker and such a gentleman.
Catherine F.
"... took care of me through every stage."
Ed guided and took care of me through every stage. Any question I had or concern he would explain the situation, options and how we overcome it to resolve the best outcome for me.
Ed H.
Online Ratings
Practice Areas
View AllEdward Palermo Is Ready To Assist
Criminal Charges I Handle in Montauk and the East End
People often think “criminal defense” means one type of case. In reality, it can involve many different allegations, each with its own procedures, defenses, and penalties.
DWI and Drugged Driving
A DWI arrest can lead to license suspension, fines, mandatory programs, ignition interlock requirements, and a criminal record. It can also threaten certain jobs and professional licenses.
I look closely at traffic stop legality, field sobriety testing, breath or blood testing issues, and whether the police followed required procedures. Even small procedural errors can change the outcome of your case.
Learn more about New York DWI laws and defenses
Drug Charges
Drug cases can range from simple possession to allegations involving intent to sell. How the evidence was found matters enormously. If your rights were violated during a search, that can change everything.
I examine whether the police had lawful justification, whether they obtained proper warrants, and whether the prosecution can actually prove possession and knowledge beyond a reasonable doubt.
Assault and Domestic Disputes
These cases are often messy and emotional, and they can escalate quickly—especially when there’s a family or relationship component. Orders of protection, restricted contact, and immediate court appearances can hit you before you fully understand what you’re facing.
I work to stabilize the situation, protect your rights, and challenge unreliable or exaggerated accusations.
More about domestic violence defense
Theft, Shoplifting, and Larceny
A theft allegation can follow you for years, even if you believe it was a misunderstanding. Surveillance footage, witness statements, and the intent element are frequently contested. My job is to challenge the evidence and pursue outcomes that minimize long-term damage.
Learn about grand larceny defense
Criminal Mischief, Trespass, and Property Offenses
On the East End, these charges sometimes arise from disputes involving property lines, vacation rentals, misunderstandings, or heated arguments. These cases often turn on what you knew, what you intended, and whether the prosecution is overcharging the situation.
Weapons Charges
Weapons allegations can carry serious penalties, even when a person had no criminal intent. These cases require careful analysis of possession, legality, stop-and-search issues, and any statements made to law enforcement.
Sex Offense Allegations
These are among the most serious cases a person can face, with extreme consequences if convicted. They must be handled with urgency and discretion.
Defense work in these matters focuses on challenging credibility, timelines, digital evidence, and investigative methods—while protecting your rights and reputation throughout the process.
Violations of Probation or Court Orders
If you’re accused of violating probation, an order of protection, or another court condition, you can face immediate consequences. The court often moves fast in these situations. I move even faster.
The Criminal Defense Process: What to Expect
Every case is different, but most criminal matters follow a general path:
Arraignment
This is typically your first court appearance. Bail, release conditions, and orders of protection may be addressed. What happens here can affect everything that follows. Having an attorney present at arraignment is critical.
Investigation and Evidence Review
Police reports are not the full story. I review allegations, video evidence, witness statements, lab reports, and any constitutional issues. I also look for missing pieces and contradictions that can help your defense.
Motion Practice
If the police acted improperly or evidence was obtained unlawfully, motions can be a turning point. Suppression motions can weaken or even dismantle a case when the facts support it.
Negotiation or Trial Preparation
Not every case should go to trial, and not every case should be pled out. The right strategy depends on your goals, your risk tolerance, the evidence, and your background. My job is to give you clear guidance and fight for the best available result.
Consequences of a Criminal Conviction
The court penalty is only part of the problem. A conviction can also affect:
- Employment background checks
- Professional licensing and certifications
- Immigration status for non-citizens
- Housing applications
- Custody disputes and family court issues
- Firearms rights
- Travel and international entry (including Canada)
That’s why defense isn’t just about “beating” a charge. It’s about minimizing damage and protecting your future.
What Makes an Effective Defense Strategy
A real defense strategy is built from the ground up, not copied from a template. Depending on the situation, that can include:
- Challenging the stop, arrest, or search
- Attacking witness reliability or inconsistencies
- Exposing gaps in proof and chain of custody issues
- Using expert review when appropriate
- Negotiating from a position of leverage
- Positioning the case for dismissal, reduction, or alternative resolution
The earlier you start, the more options you tend to have.
Montauk Cases Need a Local, Practical Approach
Montauk isn’t just another zip code. The East End has its own rhythm—seasonal tourism, busy summer weekends, crowded bars and beaches, and situations that can escalate quickly in public settings.
I’ve been appearing in East End courthouses for over three decades. I know the prosecutors, the judges, and how cases move through the system here. I approach these cases with practical judgment and attention to detail, because prosecutors and courts often make assumptions based on the allegations alone. Your defense has to cut through that and stay anchored in facts.
Contact Ed Palermo Today
If you’re facing charges in Montauk or anywhere on the East End, don’t wait for things to get worse. The smartest move is to get advice early—before you talk yourself into a corner or miss an opportunity to protect your record.
I offer free consultations and am available when you need me.
East Hampton Office
9 Willow Lane
East Hampton, NY 11937
(631) 265-1051
Suffolk County Office
1300 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Suite 320
Hauppauge, NY 11788
(631) 265-1052
Nassau County Office
1 Old Country Rd, Suite 265
Carle Place, NY 11514
(516) 280-2160
Text Ed Directly
(631) 903-3733
A Montauk criminal defense attorney should be ready to move quickly, explain your options clearly, and fight for an outcome that protects your future. That’s exactly what I do.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
What should I do immediately after being arrested in Montauk?
Stay calm and be polite with police, but do not answer questions about the incident beyond providing basic identification. Do not consent to searches. Contact a criminal defense attorney as soon as possible—ideally before making any statements. Call me at (631) 265-1051 or text (631) 903-3733.
Will a Montauk arrest appear on my record?
An arrest may appear on background checks even if you're not convicted. However, if charges are dismissed or reduced to a non-criminal violation, you may have options to limit what appears on your record. The outcome of your case matters significantly for your long-term record.
Can I lose my job over a criminal charge in New York?
It depends on your profession and employer. Certain licensed professionals—doctors, nurses, teachers, financial advisors, real estate agents—face potential disciplinary action from licensing boards. Even for non-licensed positions, a conviction can affect employment. That's why aggressive defense and pursuing the best possible outcome is so important.
How much does a Montauk criminal defense attorney cost?
Legal fees vary based on the complexity of your case and the charges involved. I offer free initial consultations where we can discuss your situation and what representation would involve. The cost of not having proper representation—a conviction, job loss, or damaged reputation—is often far greater than attorney fees.
What's the difference between a misdemeanor and a felony in New York?
Misdemeanors are less serious offenses carrying up to one year in jail. Felonies are more serious and can result in state prison sentences exceeding one year. Both can create permanent criminal records that affect your future. Even misdemeanor charges deserve serious defense.
Can you help if I was arrested somewhere else on the East End?
Yes. I handle criminal cases throughout the East End, including East Hampton, Southampton, Sag Harbor, Amagansett, Bridgehampton, and Riverhead. My East Hampton office serves clients across this entire region.
Honors & Recognition
